A valid criticism of evolution doesn’t involve ID
A valid criticism of evolution doesn’t involve ID. ID is basically saying, screw the mountains of research, data, and fossil record everything was magically poofed into existence by the Christian God. If a Muslim, Hindi, etc. started demanding that they discuss their religion’s version of creation the people who push these laws forward would start screaming bloody murder.
A valid criticism of evolution(which isn’t a criticism, but more of a debate within the theory of evolution) would actually be something like this, “Well we aren’t sure exactly if it is natural selection or mutation that pushes evolution forward, let’s look at the two theories and you can make your own informed opinion based on this data.”